October 27, 2020

Muay Thai vs Wing Chun: Differences and Effectiveness

Muay Thai and Wing Chun might be classes apart, however, they do share one common aspect. Close combat lethality.

While Muay Thai’s quick and powerful strikes can knock out an opponent in seconds, the swiftness of Wing Chun is hard to catch, especially if you are on the receiving end, and already thrown to the ground.

Of course in the modern world with modern weapons, Muay Thai is the perfect call against dangerous opponents. 

Both Muay Thai and Wing Chun are survival tactic-style martial arts approaches, with a focus on battlefield tactics. And with their history tracing back centuries, MT and WC are nothing short of menacing martial arts. 

Let us look into more details to know about these rightfully famous martial art techniques:

The Birthplace

On the one hand, there is Muay Thai. Muay Thai’s birth was in Thailand, under the name of Muay Boran. It evolved from Krabi Krabong around the mid-19th century. 

Muay Thai was built on the notion of creating a last resort for unarmed soldiers to brawl against armed opponents. 

With time, Muay Thai took inspiration from an array of other combat styles, namely Kickboxing and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. 

Muay Thai in present times retains its aggressive and quick approach to turn close combat to its advantage, by throwing off an enemy with teeps, punches, and powerful strikes. 

On the other hand, is the traditional and fearful Wing Chun. The origin of the martial art has complicated transcripts but is known to have been birthed during the transitional Civil War between the Ming and Qing Dynasties. 

The practitioner monks of Shaolin temple were faced with mortal atrocities, some of whom were able to escape and practice Wing Chun further in secrecy. 

The training hence on was for finding weak points to jab and exploit the enemies. This was a target to take over Qing soldiers on the battlefield. 

Wing Chun’s identity comes from Yim Wing Chun, the daughter of Yim Yee the Shaolin Kung Fu master who fled during the temple burn. 

Wing Chun began receiving its exposure through Bruce Lee movies and turned to form close-guarded schools in Hong Kong and Canton. 

Techniques & Training (Differences)

Wing Chun and Muay Thai differ in terms of initial practices. 

While Muay Thai offers a beginner-friendly starting course, Wing Chun requires deep knowledge of Kung-Fu and ancient martial arts. 

The approaches vary in terms of techniques and first-time classes, giving their practitioners varied time-frames to practice and prepare for real-life fights. 

The Initial Understandings of the Martial Arts Practices

Practitioners of Wing Chun look to start their schools as it is important to carry on the legacy. Wing Chun is known for its swiftness and fluidity. But it is more than just the physical traps and hard punches. 

Wing Chun portrays a chain-usage of quick footwork, timely grappling, standing leg-locks, pushes, takedowns, and more. There is no stopping a fighter when the brawling ensues.

While Wing Chun bases itself on strict discipline, Muay Thai adheres to purely offensive techniques with the sole purpose to escape quickly. 

The aim here is to clear up the engagement quickly and leave the enemy writhing in pain.

Wing chun practice wooden dummy

Training Method

Wing Chun holds its simplicity over the need to be overtly menacing. However, Muay Thai training can help you learn about real-life self-defense within the first few classes. 

WC’s time required to practice on the chain of complex move-sets, create sequential fighting tactics, and to train on detecting weakness can take the first 2 years of learning. 

The benefit you’ll enjoy from Wing Chun is the ability to chain quick kicks and powerful punches within a small time frame. This is of course, not a difficult tactic for a Nak Muay who can execute the chain with more power. 

If you look into a few fighting videos, you will notice that Wing Chun’s approach is more towards fighting another WC-expert. A Nak Muay follows the rule of defending themself against all. 

Which One is More Effective?

Muay Thai and Wing Chun are both effective in different situations and moments. However, Wing Chun has a higher ground when it comes to utilizing it at the right time. 

Adaptability

Wing Chun much to the concept of martial art, befits every enthusiast of any shape, size, gender, and even physical capability. 

Although Wing Chun is no gentle art, it is inclusive of all. The martial art form focuses on flexibility and the body’s performance over strength. 

Muay Thai is a beginner-friendly martial arts approach but requires immense strength and vigor to deliver. As a practitioner, you will need to be fit and able for every move to be perfect, aggressive, and quick. 

Muay Thai is the art of 8 limbs, requiring you to lash and block with your elbows, hands, feet, and knees. Meaning, there is no space to skim out any training. 

While an enemy might guess but become unable to block a Muay Thai strike, a Wing Chun punch comes unannounced. 

Modern gym facility in Bangkok, young athletes training for a Muay Thai class,

Practicality 

While Muay Thai and Wing Chun both share the practice of unarmed fights, the difference lies in the aim of the combat. 

Muay Thai is about throwing an opponent off their feet, using strong strikes and kicks. Maintaining a distance to ward of further attacks is the key. 

However, in the practical world, you can find your enemy anywhere. Meaning it can either be on the streets or a narrow alley. 

And distancing yourself will be more of a challenge solely due to lack of space. 

Here is where Wing Chun takes its course. The martial art is meant for an urban setup, hence excelling in close-combat through and through. 

The martial arts approach is full of surprises. It is direct, lethal, and suitable in all situations. 

Which one is better for Street Fight? 

Street fights are nothing like the ones inside the rings. You are not expected to carry teeth guard, knee braces, or gloves. 

These are hostile situations, which can turn out bloody for you, especially if you do not play your moves right. 

While Wing Chun can favor as a quick and light takedown to flee, Muay Thai moves are strong, relentless, and unforgettable to the enemy. 

Hence, Muay Thai is the born leader for a street fight. 

Let us understand this better through some points on Muay Thai’s advantage over Wing Chun

The Advantages of Muay Thai over Wing Chun

1.All Round Defense and Offence

Wing Chun follows a single path of attacks and defense, i.e. the frontal. Although these handiworks are powerful, they lack guarding from the side. 

What this does is keep every other angle to attack through, open to the opponent. And that is dangerous to a Wing Chun fighter. 

But on the other hand, a Nak Muay does not follow anyone’s angle. The art of 8 limbs follows nothing but the raw aggression to hit and block everything in its path. 

Hence, unlike a Wing Chun fighter, a Nak Muay can easily take up more than one opponent and floor them without a second thought. 

2.The Position of Hands

The defensive strategy for most martial arts follow the simple rule of using arms for a frontal guard. However, Wing Chun fighters keep their arms low to the side, thus exposing their chin and chest area for lethal blows. 

And with the possibility of such attacks coming from multiple angles, it is advisable to keep a higher guard. 

And that is exactly what a Nak Muay does. In Muay Thai, you will need to block with your elbows and also attack oncoming shin kicks. 

The high elbow guard from either end also blocks any face-punches or kicks from multiple attackers. 

3.Movement

Wing Chun has minimal footwork unless necessary. Where it scores a point as the perfect approach to take down in crummy places, it lacks in mobility. 

Muay Thai of course is all about footwork. A Nak Muay does their best in changing position every split second, making it difficult for anyone to aim at and attack. 

And last but not the least, strength play. 

Wing Chun might be swift, but the raw aggression and strength that Muay Thai fighters possess ultimately work wonders in defeating an opponent.

Which One is Better for Self-defense?

Self-Defense is more than just blocks. Sometimes, blocks stun and choke-holds play a vital part in surviving a fight. 

And survival in the modern world is possible only through aggression. And where Wing Chun lacks in aggression, Muay Thai fills the space. 

It is a martial art built to fight stronger opponents with equal or higher strength. 

And how is that? let’s find out:

The Variety in the Martial Arts

A Wing Chun fighter has certain “specific” move-sets that replicate karate or boxing but is much more. However due to its one-dimensional approach of swift and soft strikes, after a while, the moves become more or less predictable. 

But a Muay Thai Nak Muay will know more. The art of 8 limbs imbibes various martial art forms, from Muay Goren, Kick-Boxing to BJJ-style grappling. 

And the variety is what keeps the martial art, more adaptive for defense against any opponent. A Nak Muay can attack, defend, and escape without serious injuries all within a matter of a few minutes.

How it Fares Against Other Arts?

While practicing Wing Chun, you might perceive the approach to sync well with its own during a competition. Meaning, a Wing Chun Fighter might only fight their best against another WC practitioner. 

And due to its singular art form, it becomes challenging to execute in the outside world. You will practice against someone who knows the same move-sets as you, but an enemy outside will have a different skill-set to tackle you.

However, Muay Thai fares brilliantly against most martial art forms, be it Karate, BJJ, or even Krav Maga. Its right amount of offensive and defensive approach strikes the perfect balance against multiple opponents.

Bruce Lee’s Wing Chun Approach

Bruce Lee trained in Wing Chun principles only after making a few changes to synchronize his martial arts style with the ancient approach. 

bruce lee enter the dragon

Some of his well-known tweaks would be:

  • Defense: Lee believed in constant movements during a fight, unlike the traditional principles of Wing Chun. He made sure to include head-movements for missing punches. 
  • Attacks: Bruce Lee also made sure to swap out the straight-line strikes with multiple-angular attacks, using finger jabs, hook punches, roundhouse kicks, and more. 
  •  Footwork: His principle of Wing Chun footwork was a perfect blend of styles followed in fencing and boxing. By doing so, he added speed to his movements. 
  • Fluidity: Lee believed in no restrictions for Wing Chun. Moreover, he encouraged last-resort techniques such as biting, headbutts, and various other non-WC approaches.

Bruce Lee’s personalized Wing Chun concept geared towards a fight-or-flight approach. However, you as an enthusiast should train in the original form before tweaking your style for any further improvement.

Cost Comparison

When you initiate your Muay Thai training sessions, you will need about 8-12 weeks of rigorous practice to hone the basic skills. 2 days of weekly training is enough and can be fruitful for a smooth transition to intermediary and the advanced stages. 

And if you are from the USA, the approximate per-session fees would come to $100. Hence a monthly package would come to $800.

From the calculation here, you will be able to save up $2400 for the first 12 weeks. 

Wing Chun training plans, on the other hand, comes with 3, 6, and 12-month options, with family discounts available in multiple facilities. 

You can avail once-a-week sessions for $22 to $30 or the unlimited training packages that go for about $32 to $40 per week. 

On a regular basis, it can take you 5 years of training to master the art of Wing Chun. Hence you can save up accordingly and opt for cost-effective packages for your training. 

Which one should I learn?

Wing Chun is all about swiftness and agility, while Muay Thai advocates raw offensive power. 

Both play their parts as some of the most popular martial art forms to exist in the 21st century. 

If you wish to learn either, you must understand your requirement, if you want to take up training as an enthusiast or as an aspiring fighter. 

If you aim to research the ancient fighting art styles through practical sessions, Wing Chun might be handy. 

However, if you wish to face reality and prepare yourself for any physical adversity be it on the road or anywhere, Krav Maga’s explosive attacks are what will keep you away from serious injuries. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *