October 27, 2020

Muay Thai vs Karate: Which One’s Better?

Muay Thai is more about quick strikes and fast escapes. Many of those who have had their hands-on experience in both Muay Thai and Karate, feel that the former is more enjoyable to learn. 

This can be mostly due to Muay Thai having quick-to-learn brawling techniques over Karate’s prolonged rigorous training. 

However, both the martial arts are unstoppable and menacing in their own ways. And their roots tell the tales better than any other. 

Read on to know more!

The Beginning

Muay Thai was a more evolved version of Krabi Krabong, a battlefield tactic popular among the Thai army around the mid-19th century. 

With its initial identity as Muay Boran, MT was the perfect unarmed offensive tactic against armed enemies. 

Muay Thai is more than aggressive movements and unrelenting strikes. It has shared tactics from kickboxing as well as Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. 

There are essences of grappling, hooks, punches, and takedowns, that helped Muay Thai ring terror in an opponent’s ear. 

Karate’s birth in Japan was also during the 18th Century. It was within the districts of Okinawa where karate began as a combat practice session. 

The exact roots of Karate are debatable. But its inclusion as a physical exercise program in Okinawa during the 1900s has helped Karate secure its spot in the world of martial arts.

The 20th century was also the year where Karate emerged as an extra-curricular activity in schools, prompting children to train for the belt, from a very young age. 

Throughout this century, karate dojos began their training all over the world to bring together a community of well-learned Japanese martial artists.  

There are various forms of Karate, namely Shotokan, Goju Ryu, and more. Each is unique and strives towards methodical self-defense approaches. 

Techniques & Training (Differences)

The training techniques of both Muay Thai and Karate differ in their approaches. Muay Thai is predominantly aggressive. A Nak Muay will waste no time to utilize their elbows, hands, knees, and legs into delivering deadly strikes. 

Muay Thai is hence, known as the art of 8 limbs. 

Karate, on the other hand, is a stand-up style of fighting. There are full contact versions of karate that focus on attack forms over the strength-aspect. 

Let us understand this through the following descriptions of MT and Karate approaches:

The Tactics’ Focus

Karate focuses on finishing a fight quickly without delivering or sustaining extreme damages. It is a stand-up fighting technique, depending heavily on a variety of kicks and punches. 

Although, elbow attacks and knee hits are also a part of the curriculum with minimal exposure. Joint locks and wrist control are also exclusive to advanced tournament fights. 

These strikes and kicks can either be hard-hitting or of light contact, depending upon the karate style used by the karateka. 

For example, Shotokan consists of weak punches and kicks while Seidokaikan is a full-contact and a hard-hitting approach. 

Footwork is of the essence in Karate as a karateka will need to be quick to nullify attacks through strong throws. 

Not to forget, this is a purely defensive approach, working towards throwing an enemy off with the minimal physical impact. 

Karatekas invest their strength more in stunning an opponent than that of harming them. 

Muay Thai is relatively quicker as an approach than that of Karate. Similar to formal martial art, Muay Thai invests its strength in powerful strikes and throws. 

And these strikes are deadly and can either throw an opponent down or make them flee the spot. 

Muay Thai tactics do not hold back from harming the enemy. The art of 8 limbs comes from tactics that involve the Nak Muay’s elbows, fists, feet, and knees. 

They are human weapons during a battle due to the number of menacing movements that take cues from kick-boxing and various MMA combat styles. 

While there is no proper training on handling take-downs in Karate, Muay Thai specializes in maintaining all fights standing up. 

Thanks to boxing’s side-to-side feet swipe and Clinching, they can dominate standing groundwork without missing their balance. 

Muay Thai is neither fully offensive or defensive. It is a balanced martial art that can aid the Nak Muay in quick finishers and strong grappling abilities. 

Arms Placement for Stances

Karatekas tend to keep their arms lowered due to competition rules. Arms are mostly near the hips and in front. 

This is as various Karate styles require varied stances for fights. Let us take the example of Kyokushin style tournaments where a karateka cannot punch an opponent’s head but can perform a roundhouse kick. 

Similarly, mild or point sparring does not require full contact and follows methodical steps to bring down an enemy. 

However, Nak Muay secures their arms stance on a higher level. The elbows stay widened on either side to strike as well as block incoming attacks. 

Muay Thai stance aims to strike down an enemy as this martial art follows no rule to reduce impact for the sake of competitive battles. 

Which One is More Effective?

In terms of effectiveness, Muay Thai scores fair points as it is more reality-based over Karate’s competitive background. 

Muay Thai’s principles rely on quick and impactful strikes with effective kicks for control. Karate, on the other hand, relies on rules of minimized impacts and more on stances to acquire points. 

Initial Training

Building up karate techniques while keeping in mind a banned contact-list can take months. Karate belt promotions and training require ample time to master due to the methodical approach. 

Karate requires years of practice and competitive exposure to master the intermediate Kumite (combative) move-sets. 

Fortunately, Muay Thai training begins on day one with sparring practices and blocking techniques. As an aspiring Nak Muay, you will require mouthguards, shoulder pads, and shin guards for full protection. 

Nak Muay does not take any slow steps in focusing on real-life fights for training purposes. 

Nak Muay’s initial training sessions include bits of everything, from menacing strikes, quick foot-work, and fast-paced kicks to gain momentum. 

The lack of ground rules is useful for a trainee who might face inescapable real-life combat situations. 

Muay Thai combat tactics are inspired by an array of martial arts and close-contact sports, making it an invincible force of power and might. 

Two mans with Muay Thai Chaiya

Competitive vs. Combative

Karate is a complicated martial art, not due to its fighting style but the list of prohibitions during sparring. An opponent against a karateka can utilize multiple fighting techniques, that also include takedowns. 

Unfortunately, counter-takedowns on escapes are rarely taught in any karate forms, resulting in the fighter losing the battle due to lack of exposure. 

Karate’s predominantly competitive background lends no real training against real-life combats. And the predictive punch to kick ratio can have minimal fear-response from an opponent. 

The scene can take a turn for a Nak Muay as MT fighting tactics are aggressive, on point, and threatening to anyone who does not know the combat sport. 

A Nak Muay can train on move-sets quicker due to minimal prohibitions on body-areas. The art of 8 limbs supports full-body offensive approaches where the fighter can use kicks to throw off the enemy after landing a flurry of punches. 

Which One is Better for Street Fighting? 

A street fight would be lethal, with an opponent’s group asking for a brawl. And here, slow, steady, and methodical sparring does not fare well. 

Hence, Muay Thai is a more responsive martial art form against street fights. The lack of ground rules provides more freedom to go at the enemy without pardoning their body. 

Moreover, most Karate forms even while encouraging full-contact, maintain a low-harm profile as the art-style is geared towards competitions. 

Muay Thai is one martial art with a single form of sparring. Its inspiration from various other combative techniques makes it stronger and more formidable. 

Woman Looking At Men Fighting On Street

Combat Styles

Karate discourages full-contact fighting. This is to maintain a safe combat environment training for competitive matches. 

But what this rule does is strip away the offensive aspect of a defensive format. For example, a karateka will stop their punch to the face by attacking that angle, without touching. This is a competition rule for certain forms.

During a match, a proper hit to the face can lead to heavy foul points. But during a real-life fight, the lack of proper offensive tactics training leaves a karateka more vulnerable. 

However, a Nak Muay will leave no stones unturned to have the opponent’s nose bleed out from their punches. A Nak Muay means business. 

They leave no stones unturned in utilizing Muay Thai tactics to handle multiple enemies. Moreover, the art of 8 limbs permits 0-space for opponents’ strikes to pass through. 

Muay Thai allows blocking and attacking through both arms and legs, making it a menacing aura to deal with during a real brawl. 

Weak Spots

A karateka might leave their weak areas in the open, due to the lack of proper defensive techniques. 

For example, the Karate stance encourages arms to be near to the belt. Doing so might help in striking out punches, but leaves the frontal body prone to kicks, strikes and more. 

Muay Thai encourages elbows to be on either side of the body, which can work as blocks or impactful attacks to shins during a match. 

A Nak Muay can guard against most approaches due to its versatile offensive/defensive stances that increase their chances to win. 

Kata to Kumite Ratio

Kumite is sparring forms while Kata is training forms. Martial artists utilize Kumite for actual combats while performing katas during competitions. 

Karate focuses on Katas over Kumites due to its prioritizing competitions over real-life combats. 

Muay Thai has no concept of Katas and focuses mainly on contact-sparring as the form of fighting. Here, blocks, strikes, and kicks come to use for training, as real-life fights do not depend on fighting forms. 

Which One is Better for Self-Defense?

Karate and Muay Thai can be individually useful and prove their purpose in different situations. 

However, self-defense involves more than blocking attacks but also countering every move with a more ferocious blow. And here, Muay Thai possesses the advantage. 

Reaction to Weapons

Weapons are an unpopular favorite among those looking to fight without a cause. And karate move-sets might not be the most suitable for these occasions. 

Karate involves swift and impactful strikes that can knock down an enemy. A punch can be blocked as and when required. But blocking a knife has no known skill-set. 

A karateka will hence, need to practice on tactics outside the discipline to prepare for real-life situations, 

Muay Thai holds the popular tag of the “Art of 8 Limbs”. Meaning, a Nak Muay can both block and counterattack with all their elbows, fists, knees, and shins. Not even a sharp object can pass through the flurry of punches and kicks which can render the enemy, unconscious. 

Muay Thai’s boxing and grappling tactics can immobilize an enemy before they raise weapons against the fighter. The swift and piercing attacks leave no stones unturned for the opponent to find your weak spot. 

Hence, Muay Thai inspires its move-sets from reality while Karate upholds tradition over brawling. 

Practice Sessions

If you are already training under the Karate discipline, make sure to test out your skills against non-karateka opponents. Doing so can help you get a taste of real-life fights, and hence hone your skills towards taking an opponent down. 

Cooperative training partners from MMA and other martial arts combats can help you identify the drawbacks in your techniques. You can hence, work on them for maximum efficiency. 

For a Nak Muay, practice sessions are fun and educational. Muay Thai enthusiasts enroll in to gather more information on a ferocious fighting style. 

Every trainee works on proper formats of balanced offensive and defensive combats, helping Nak Muays to initiate mock-fights with classmates. 

Cost Comparison

The intermediary practice stage of Muay Thai takes about 8-12 weeks to master. Hence, it is advisable to train twice a week for maximum benefits. 

In the USA, per session fees come to approximately $100. Meaning, you will need around $800 for a complete monthly package. 

Upon calculating, the total cost for the 8-12 weeks session would come to $2,400.

For Karate, depending upon the training speed, you might need 3-5 years to master tactics properly. 

If you wish to train under a personal instructor, the per-session fees would come to $25 to $50 per lesson. 

Moreover, 1 weekly class is enough to steadily prepare the building blocks of karate. Each of these classes cost around $40 per session. 

Meaning, the monthly payment structure for Karate would come to $160. You can also pay for an annual package of $1920 per month. 

Which One Should I Learn?

Both Karate and Muay Thai strive for effective self-defense against unknown attacks. 

The one you wish to learn depends upon your comfortable combat style. 

If you enjoy competitively strong matches and win gold, try out your hands on Karate. However, if you wish to prepare for real-life combative situations, Muay Thai is the solution. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *