July 27, 2021

Karate vs Wing Chun: Differences and Effectiveness

Are you confused about which one to choose between Wing Chun and Karate? Then, you are in the right place if you want to learn either of these and become a martial artist like Bruce Lee and Jean-Claude Van Damme.

Wing Chun and Karate both are from the family of martial arts and have a long history and legacy. Both teach self-defense and discipline in their varied ways, but their objective is the same. 

Karate attacks such as the punch and the chop are very quick and fatal if timed right. Placement of the attack is also given much importance when it comes to Karate. Wing Chun is a very old form of Kung fu which directs the energy opponent against him. This helps in saving your own strength and flushing the opponent at the same time. 

In this article you will get to know the differences and the intricacies which Karate and Wing Chun have to offer. This article will not only help you choose one but also give you the required knowledge to make the right choice.

So, without any further ado, let’s right jump into it.

Tracing the History 

Wing Chun, also known as Wing Chun Kuen and is a form of martial art that focuses on the quick arm and leg movements to teach the art of self-defense.

Wing Chun was developed in southern China roughly 300 years ago by Nun Ng Mui, a master of Shaolin Kung Fu. He formulated Wing Chun by using his knowledge and skill of Kung Fu. The year 1949, Yip Man, who was a disciple and student of Nun Ng, brought the style out of China to Hong Kong and then gradually to the world.

Two men in a gym practising the martial art of Wing Chun using sticks

On the other hand, the legacy of Karate can be traced back to the 17th century. Karate was first formulated on the Japanese Island of Okinawa. It was later brought to mainland Japan by various masters and students in order to expose the Japanese people to the art form. It was first taught in the Universities of Japan. Karate, when translated in English, means “empty hands and its way,” which is connotative of its techniques.

As the name suggests, Karate features only hand to hand combat, and the use of any weapons is not allowed in the sport. Karate features linear movements and is regarded as one of the most popular martial arts in the world. Karate also owes its popularity that it is considered a much more straightforward form of self-defense than any other Asian Martial Art form.

Techniques 

Wing Chun is a relatively older form of martial art compared to Karate. In Wing Chun, when a person defends an attack then the flow of that counter is towards the back of his body. In Karate, the stop up tends to go away from the body.

Wing Chun features softer stop up’s or blocks while Karate comprises hard blocking. At the same time, Wing Chun has Chinese origins, but Karate has Japanese.

The progression of the flow in Wing Chun is slow. This is done intentionally to maintain fluidity. Karate has a relatively fast advance and is fast-paced. In Karate, there are three stances. Whereas in Wing Chun, there are two.

Forms

The forms of Wing Chun include:

  1. Biu Gee or Thrusting Fingers 
  2. Bart Cham Dao or Eight cutting Knives
  3. Siu Nim Tao or Little Idea
  4. Luk Dim Boon Gwun or Six and a half point pole
  5. Chum Kiu or Bridge seeking
  6. Muk Yan Jong or Wooden Dummy

The forms of Karate include:

  1. Shotokan
  2. Goju ryu
  3. Shito ryu
  4. Wado ryu

Similarities

Wing Chun and Karate also have many similarities. These similarities are more than between any other martial art forms. Both Wing Chun and Karate feature forms of hand to hand combat.

As far as blocking goes, Wing Chun and Karate rely on one arm to block and then to concurrently attack with the other one. Wing Chun and Karate were born in the same continent of Asia.

Balance is critical when it comes to Wing Chun or Karate. The practitioners of Wing Chun and Karate are always taught to give prime importance to balance and form. Without these two, timing a perfect punch or a chop becomes very complicated. 

Which is More Effective in a Street Fight?

Wing Chun is more effective.

In a life-threatening scenario, no matter which martial art you know, the thing that matters most is how you can maintain your calm and fight.Like every other martial art, Wing Chun too has a peculiar method. 

Wing Chun uses these peculiar methods and course of action in order to get the desired result. 

In an event like a street fight which requires you to defend yourself against any bodily-harm, there are no set of rules involved. Your adversary will do anything to throw you to the ground and incapacitate you.

Hence, the issue arises from the fact that if you will be able to adapt. It’s highly unlikely that you will get into a physical altercation with a person who also knows Wing Chun outside your wing Chun school. Chances are that he will be a layman. So you can easily block his punches and attacks. 

The issue is that when the person tries to grapple you or uses any other style of street fighting, then it becomes tough to adapt, engage, and dominate.

Your chances are dependent upon three factors – 

  • Your Training.
  • Your Adaptability.
  • Your Mental Equilibrium.

If you have these covered then you can get out a victor in any life-threatening situation which requires you to fight.

Karate can also be reasonably useful in the situation of a street – fight. With the combination of a low stance and fast hand and feet movements, you can easily stun your opponent. 

In Karate, you can even knock out a person who is physically bigger and stronger than you. This becomes possible because a learned karate specialist knows your weak points and can capitalize on that.

A karate specialist boasts the ability to knock out anyone in the blink of an eye. However, Karate is a sport, and this is the reason which keeps the person from making any unlawful movies.

This can also work against him/her in a real-life scenario as the other person might be using illegal and raw moves to counter.

Your winnability in a life-threatening scenario depends upon your ability to make the first move and strike hard, with precision, which will render your opponent incapacitated to make any further moves.

Which is better in Self – Defense?

Both Karate and Wing Chun can be used to defend ourselves. But, Karate holds a higher ground when it comes to self-defense as it has many variations that hold importance in the real world.

Self – Defense techniques are something that every person should know. We all have the right to defend ourselves against any bodily harm by any other person.

Karate focuses more on rigid blows whereas Wing Chun uses circular movements to counter-attacks and then also to render some damage. A person, who has proficient training in any of these can easily knock out the other person if he is able to recall the techniques and adapt during the confrontation.

Wing Chun is an ornate style of martial arts while Karate is blunt and to the point. 

The whole mechanism and nature of Karate is more similar to real-world scenarios than Wing Chun. A well trained karateka can easily read the body language of the opponent before he even makes his move.

In a self defense situation, the aggression will definitely make the first move. This gives Karate the upper hand as even a block will render more damage than a chop or a punch.

Which is Easier to Learn?

Nothing comes easy. If you are looking to be a professional or a specialist, then be prepared; you are in it for the long haul. The basics of Karate can be taught to you in the span of six to eight months. The rest depends on you and your training regime.

Becoming a master takes a lifetime in any martial art form, and Karate is no exception. You can be significant and better than many in four to five years of starting your training. Most people are able to get a black belt in Karate in six to eight years if they are regular.

In exceptional cases, people also have been able to earn it in a span of four years. As far as wing Chun is concerned, it takes a much longer time to learn even the basics as there are many different techniques to learn.

Wing Chun is a form of martial art that defies the basic human impulse to block an attack rigidly; hence a complete overhaul of mind is required to teach a student to block in a softer manner. 

A novice can learn the basics in a year or so. Students become very confident after five years of practice. But, if you want to become a master then you are looking at 15 – 25 years of continuous practice and training. 

Which One Should You Choose?

Still, confused between the two? Let me lay it out bare for you.

If you are someone who is looking to pursue combat training to achieve self-defense and fitness in a shorter span of time, then Karate is the way to go. Karate is something that better fits the routine of office goers and working individuals. 

You can easily take an hour, three days a week, and learn Karate. A karate trainer is also relatively easier to find than Wing Chun. Karate requires less space, and since it is all hand to hand combat which makes it more convenient to learn.

Wing Chun is something which requires a little more commitment as it requires more time. So if you are in your early teens then you can take up wing Chun as you have time on your side. By the age of 20 you can be very proficient. 

You can also participate in competitions that are organized all across the US. Starting Wing Chun at such an early age will also keep you fit and will also help in strengthening and conditioning your body from an early age.  

Comparisons

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *